28 September 2012

Fewer US TV Households Because of Fewer Used TV Sets

Nielsen recently announced that the universe of US TV households would be reduced for the 2012-2013 television season by 500,000. TV set penetration is now 96.7% of US households, down from 98.9% the prior year.

The company attributed the decline to 3 factors:

  1. Digital Transition: The summer of 2009 marked a significant milestone with a shift from analog to digital broadcasting. Following the transition, consumers were only able to view digital broadcasts via a set with a built-in digital tuner (i.e., a newer TV set) or an analog TV set connected to a digital-to-analog converter box, cable or satellite. TV penetration first dipped after this transition; the permanence of this trend was acknowledged in 2010 after the number of TV households did not rebound over time.
  2. Economics: As with previous periods of belt-tightening, the cost of owning a TV is a factor in this UE decline; TV penetration first saw sustained decreases in second quarter 2009. Lower-income, rural homes were particularly affected.
  3. Multiple Platforms: Nielsen data demonstrates that consumers are viewing more video content across all platforms—rather than replacing one medium with another. However, a small subset of younger, urban consumers are going without paid TV subscriptions. Long-term effects of this are unclear, as it’s undetermined if this is also an economic issue, with these individuals entering the TV marketplace once they have the means, or the beginning of a larger shift to viewing online and on mobile devices.

This is a TV set.
The first two factors also combine in another way. Many (probably most) of the TV sets in households prior to the digital transition were analog sets. Unless they are connected to a converter box (or cable or DBS receiver), they are no longer TV sets, because they can't be used to watch...TV. The cost of a usable television set has effectively gone up, since there are no cheap, old, working digital sets to be handed down to friends and family or found at the thrift store.
This is no longer a TV set.
While the penetration of TV sets will likely drift up over the next few years as digital sets trickle down, the matter of TV set penetration may no longer be significant. A person watching, say, ABC programming on a laptop or tablet is watching television for all practical purposes and Nielsen will inevitably address this reality in their universe estimates and ratings in the near future.

27 September 2012

OTT Growing or Not Growing?

A recent study by the NPD Group bore the headline that "nearly half of all paid VOD movie rental orders generated by cable companies". There's no great shock there, after all, cable VOD is widely available. What is surprising is that NPD found that cable movie rental VOD is taking share from Internet-delivered movie rental VOD. Cable movie rental VOD increased by 24% since last year while Internet-delivered movie rental VOD (e.g., iTunes, Amazon Instant, Vudu) increased by only 15% (measuring first half 2012 versus first half 2011, to be precise).
Far more intuivitively, a few days later the same group noted that TVs are becoming the primary screen for home viewing of online video. This would appear to be a strong sign for the growth of over-the-top video.

What could account for relative strength of cable movie rental VOD in the face of greater over-the-top presence on TV sets?

The first NPD study is movie rental only. It does not include movies watched as part of an SVOD service like Netflix or Amazon Prime. (It also does not include movies purchased, rather than rented, but cable operators rarely sell movies and iTunes et al do, so movie purchases can't be tipping the scale in cable's  favor). If the number of movies rented were going down, then Netflix streaming could have been a factor, but that was not the case -- both cable and Internet movie rental VOD showed double digit growth.

Interestingly, an earlier NPD study about VOD movie rental (the subject of my prior post here) found that pay-TV VOD declined by 12% from the prior year (August 2011 versus August 2010 to be precise) among users of Internet-delivered VOD.

While all of these studies are measured slightly different things, perhaps the pay-TV providers have improved their promotion of movie rental VOD or have improved the navigation of the choices or have streamlined the buying process. Whatever they have done, it seems to be working, and far more successfully than I would have imagined possible.

An addition: Perhaps cable has been a bigger beneficiary than Internet-delivery from the demise of bricks-and-mortar movie rental places.

11 September 2012

What Have We Learned About Over-the-Top Video and What We Can Expect To See



The fragmentation of over-the-top devices is a tremendous pain for programmers. Not only do Roku, Samsung Blu-ray players, Sony TVs, XBoxes and iPhones require separately produced apps, they often require separately encoded video. The implication is that only the most ubiquitous programmers (e.g., Netflix) will find it worthwhile to be on every platform and that the smaller programmers will go to the most open ("small" here, means, in part "can't afford the risk of having my app be rejected") and popular platform, which is probably very good news for Roku. This area of the business is bound for a shakeout.

Over-the-top programming is already very competitive with cable offerings in a few small areas of the business: new hit movies (can be rented from iTunes as easily as cable VOD), out-of-market sports packages other than the DirecTV-exclusive NFL Sunday Ticket (e.g., MLB Extra Innings) and adult video (see prior post on this topic). Over-the-top is least competitive with cable in offering basic and premium cable networks. Aereo, if it survives the legal challenges it faces, represents a portion of the package, for those who can not or do not want to use their own antenna to pick up free broadcast television.

It is difficult to imagine that over-the-top video will have the same access to "cable" content in the future than it had in the past. Cable programmers make too much money selling their services to multichannel distributors (and the advertising on such services to major national advertisers). Starz walking away from renewing a deal Netflix is the best example of this. As noted in a New York Times article about the 2012 DirecTV-Viacom deal "free access to people who don’t subscribe to DirecTV or another similar distributor is likely to become more restrictive, thereby fortifying the existing model of TV distribution." Someday over-the-top providers might be able to provide some programmers with enough money to make it worth their while to jeopardize their relationships with traditional multichannel distributors, but that day does not appear to be in the next year or two. Nothing -- short of new governmental regulation, that is -- can force a critical mass of cable programmers to sell to the potential disruptors of the multichannel ecosystem.

Over-the-top programming often requires juggling multiple devices and subscriptions. The most satisfying way to "replace" a multichannel subscription probably involves a combination of Netflix, Hulu Plus, iTunes rentals, Aereo, Roku services, over-the-air broadcast signals, etc. and none of them are available on any one device. (Although apps like Fanhattan could help consumer's manage the juggling).

Over-the-top content providers can and will develop their own original content, but it is unclear if this content will be a suitable replacement for a multichannel subscription. Netflix with its original content initiative and YouTube with its investment in original channels are pouring resources into original programming. If there is a return on this investment and it continues, it will make over-the-top more attractive. On some level it does not matter if the new content is a good substitute for what comes with a multichannel subscription, programming is rarely a zero-sum game. The growth of VHS rental didn't hamper the growth of cable subscriptions, but it did destroy the repertory movie house. One notes that the last attempt to enter the multichannel business head-on with original content was Cablevision's Voom and that didn't work out very well.

The rising price of a multichannel video subscription is the one given. With more distributor competition (hello, Google Fiber), the programmers are in a strong position to raise prices. Even Viacom (which "lost" the PR battle in its standoff with DirecTV), still managed to get a 20% price increase -- not bad for a losing effort, if not the 30% they had sought initially.

The distributors, resigned to paying more for content, are seeing what they CAN get at the negotiating table. Two things come to mind: greater TV Everywhere rights (an interesting #1 on this list) and greater restrictions on the amount and quality of content that cable programmers can put online for free or sell to over-the-top providers. Given the small incremental cost of the former and the relatively small revenue contribution over-the-top sources are providing today, these tradeoffs are not that difficult for cable programmers to accept.
The metaphorical "pricing umbrella"

As multichannel prices rise, to the extent that TV Everywhere is very valuable to the consumer, he or she will be content. To the extent that it isn't that valuable, he or she is a loser. However, the consumer facing a higher multichannel bill now has more incentive (and more money) to consider alternatives. In other words, the higher multichannel bill creates a pricing umbrella for over-the-top video.
This is NOT what I mean by over-the-top video

29 June 2012

Now AT&T Wants to Drop AMC's Networks

It looks like AMC Networks is heading for two showdowns tomorrow, as AT&T has joined Dish in threatening to yank the programmer's channels. While the cover story is the same for both distributors -- the proposed rates for AMC's channels are too high and represent a poor value -- the story is more credible for AT&T. Dish, after all, is facing what appears to be the losing end of a lawsuit with AMC Networks over the defunct Voom networks and, if dropping the AMC services can improve the terms of that settlement, that's pretty rational behavior (my prior post on this subject). AT&T has no such issue. The following statement is on AT&T's web site for program disputes:  att.com/fighting4you (obviously, AT&T is planning to have more similar disputes). Knowing how these sort of things are often taken down after a settlement, I am reposting it here for posterity:

The AT&T* U-verse® TV contract with AMC Networks for channels including AMC, IFC and WE tv, expires at 11:59 p.m. EST on June 30. AT&T issued the following statement:
We are making every effort to reach a fair agreement and continue providing these channels to our customers. Frankly, we’re disappointed AMC Networks has decided to take its negotiations public, instead of working with us in good faith, especially since we’re still actively in negotiations. We’ve been in ongoing negotiations to renew this agreement, but AMC Networks is seeking an excessive rate increase in our overall fees for the right to deliver these channels. AMC Networks is asking thatAT&T pay what we believe is nearly double what other competitors pay - including a smaller-sized competitor. We believe the rates they are seeking are disproportionate compared to the viewership we see across their channels. We don’t think that’s reasonable, especially in these economic times, and we will continue to work toward a fair deal.
There’s an ongoing industry trend in which an increasing number of content providers seek unreasonable price increases from their service providers as those contracts expire. If we accept this cost increase from AMC Networks, it could result in higher prices for customers, and would only encourage other content providers to make similar demands. We don’t want customers to lose these channels, but we need to take a stand now to keep costs down while continuing to provide the quality programming customers want and deserve.
Observers of the industry know that this statement suggests a desire, on the part of AT&T, for Most Favored Nation treatment with respect to its rates for the AMC Networks services and that AT&T has passed AMC's former parent, Cablevision, in terms of basic cable subscribers, per the National Cable Television Association. The merits of AT&T's position can be debated and I suspect are not relevant at all to consumers. Fundamentally, AT&T is making a wise move if the AMC channels are not bringing benefits to their customers equal to their prices. Analyses of channel value are often pretty hard to do, except at the extremes -- the channels that are worth little are usually not difficult to negotiate and those worth a lot are generally well understood. The interesting part of AT&T's negotiation is the opportunity that presented itself to AT&T -- to pick a second fight with a programmer already fighting one battle. As any general knows, it is nice when the opponent's army is divided. One thing that I do know, no customer subscribes to cable TV to NOT get the channels they want. Typically settlements of these disputes are reached in a modest amount of time. A key date for this one is 15 July 2012, the date of the season premiere of AMC's acclaimed drama Breaking Bad.


Updated (3 July 2012): AT&T and AMC Networks settled shortly after the old deal's midnight expiration without any inconvenience to AT&T subscribers. As is usual, the financial details were not disclosed.

15 June 2012

More on the Ikea TV

While the focus of my work (and this site) is the business of television, especially its distribution, I have become enchanted with the concept of a simpler TV experience. Navigation could be a whole lot better (both within the channel guide and between the different possible sources of material) and someone, someday, will do something about the multitude of wires (that is someone other than a custom A/V installer).

I wrote about the Ikea TV (product name Uppleva) in an earlier post. At the time it was little more than a press release, but a new article reveals a lot more about the product (which is due to be released in Italy, France, Germany, Poland, and, natch, Sweden, later this month) and the concept is growing on me the more I read about it.
What I like about the Ikea offering is that it appears to have done a very nice job of addressing the input issues (i.e., switching among them) and the wiring issues (i.e., having to look at them). If the screen and speakers they use are good, this might actually be something that I would recommend to others. If the screen and speakers they use are not-so-good, but easily replaceable, it might be something I'd consider, despite a deep-seated aversion to particle board. 

The Uppleva is due to arrive Stateside in April 2013.

04 June 2012

Dish-AMC Fight Breaks Out on a New Front -- Channel Placement

According to deadline.com, last night Dish escalated its fight with AMC Networks by relocating several of its channels from their usual places on the dial to the television equivalent of Siberia. While distributors typically have the right to determine the placement of a channel on their lineups, the point is often negotiated and I don't recall ever seeing this sort of move used as a negotiating tactic.


  • AMC moved from channel 130 to channel 9609 (SD) and 9610 (HD)
  • WeTV moved from channel 128 to channel 9608
  • IFC moved from channel 393 to channel 9607


To complete the picture:

Before:
127 Oxygen
128 WeTV
129 Bravo
130 AMC
131 IFC
132 Turner Classic Movies
133 Fox Movie Channel

After:
127 Oxygen
128 Style
129 Bravo
130 HDNet
131 Indieplex
132 Turner Classic Movies
133 Fox Movie Channel

As far as I can best tell, the AMC Networks channels' new neighbors are:

9414 V-me
9415 Free Speech TV
9417 EWTN
9607 IFC
9608 WeTV
9609 AMC
9610 AMC HD
9701 Racetrack Television Network

As a negotiating tactic for Dish, its got its advantages. Moving a channel to a less trafficked neighborhood should reduce live viewing and, to the extent that Dish's DVRs don't keep up with the change, it could reduce DVR viewing as well. The substitution of Style in WeTV's slot makes some sense; Style is now between its corporate siblings which cross-promote each other. Style is a nationally rated network with a defined niche. Content-wise Indieplex is somewhat similar to IFC, but with much less of a profile (for those unfamiliar, it has indie and art movies from the Starz and Encore libraries). Mark Cuban's HDNet is not at all like AMC, nor is it nearly as well known (and it will get less well known when it rebrands as AXS TV during the summer). Generally speaking, subscribers never like channel lineup changes -- change is disruptive and typically offers no apparent benefit, so Dish didn't do this to make its customers happier. As for Dish's explanation of the reason for the change "the new positions better reflect the channels' ratings", to be charitable, that seems most unlikely.

Added commentary on the matter, courtesy of Louis Peitzman of Jezebel: "In the ultimate dick move, Dish responded by relocating AMC to channel 9069 — right in the middle of a broadcast of The Killing." Nice turn of phrase.


09 May 2012

TV is the Dominant Platform for Watching TV

The Nielsen Company has released its annual The Cross-Platform Report for 4Q11 (registration required) and it contains some interesting bits, none more interesting to me than this chart.

The thing that jumps out to me, is that for all the talk in the multichannel industry about TV Everywhere -- watching what you want, when you want and where you want -- the dominant way to watch video is on TV.

Even in the groups that watch the most video on phones and on computers, such viewing is a small fraction of the total. This is a developing area and viewing will increase as more people have video-enabled phones. Also, demographic forces are pretty clearly going to increase online viewing as these 65+ people in this chart become a smaller part of the mix ("die off" sounds a bit harsh) and are replaced by today's younger people who will probably continue to use online video they way they have been (in other words, more than today's older people do).

What one always wonders about trends is whether this will transform the industry or effectively obliterate it? In other words, is the impact "DVR on the TV business" or "computer on the typewriter business"?
Making TV more convenient to view with result in more viewing. Convenience adds to consumption. Robert Woodruff, Coca-Cola's president, expressed his goal of putting the drink "within an arm's reach of desire" in 1923. That worked out pretty well for increasing the consumption of Coca-Cola.

However, portable TV is not an entirely new concept. I remember fondly receiving this as a gift in my early days in the television business.

Sony FDL-22 handheld television (1998) for more info
In its day, it was a pretty exotic piece of kit, but eventually languished for all of the now-obvious practical reasons. We didn't want a separate device just for watching TV on the go.

The mobile part of TV Everywhere sure looks like added value to the multichannel subscription rather than a separate video subscription. Verizon V-Cast, MobiTV and Media Flo have all found that they are either out of the mobile video business or have morphed the sale or sales pitch to be an adjunct to the sale of a mobile data plan. We didn't want a separate subscription just for watching TV on the go.

If there is any company that knows the value of TV Everywhere it is Netflix, since it is on virtually every possible video-viewing platform, but look at the breakdown of its usage...
click here for the Nielsen blog post from which this chart came
For clarity, this is a chart of how many users use the platform for watching Netflix (or Hulu), not how much they watch on the platform, but it is pretty clear that iPad and mobile phone usage are pretty far down the list and fit better into the concept of special use cases than primary usage. As regards watching long form video on a computer, I think most everyone has enough experience with that experience to draw their own conclusion on the attractiveness and/or use cases versus watching video on a television.

TV is the dominant platform for watching TV and likely will be for a long time. TV Everywhere is well worth providing, but strictly added value to the core usage.

Now, if someone delivers a quality service to your mobile phone and then you can painlessly send it to your big TV in high quality (like via AirPlay using an Apple TV)...that's a whole different competitive dynamic.